Two neighbors, same house, same roof, same claims history. One pays $1,480 a year for homeowners insurance; the other pays $2,910. The difference is not the property. It is a three-digit number most homeowners do not know exists, have never seen, and cannot easily check: the credit-based insurance score. Nine states restrict or ban it outright, and the rules changed again in 2026. Here is the actual map, how much it moves your premium, and what you can do about it this week.

It is not your FICO score
A credit-based insurance score is built from your credit report, but it is not the score a lender sees. Insurers weight different variables, and depending on the model they may lean on:
- Payment history on non-mortgage accounts (the heaviest factor in most models)
- Length of credit history and number of open accounts
- Collections, public records, and prior bankruptcies
- Outstanding balances relative to limits (utilization)
- Number of recent inquiries for new credit
Notably absent from most models: income, race, marital status, age, and whether you own or rent your home. That exclusion list is statutory, not voluntary โ and it is the reason the score survives legal challenge in the states that still permit it.
Where credit scoring is banned or restricted in 2026
| State | Rule | Practical effect |
|---|---|---|
| California | Banned for auto and homeowners (Prop 103) | Insurers cannot use credit at all for personal lines. Expect underwriting to lean harder on claims history and territory. |
| Maryland | Banned for homeowners | Auto may still use it; homeowners cannot. |
| Massachusetts | Banned for homeowners | Same split as Maryland โ auto permitted, home not. |
| Utah | Banned for homeowners (with narrow exceptions) | Insurers may not use credit to decline, surcharge, or non-renew a homeowner policy. |
| Nevada | Banned for homeowners | Auto continues to allow it under filing rules. |
| Oregon | Restricted for personal lines | Permitted with limits; insurers must show actuarial justification and cannot use it as the sole factor. |
| Washington | Restricted, sunset-linked | Legislative fights recur; check the current effective date before assuming. |
| Hawaii, Michigan, New Jersey | Restricted use / adverse-action rules | Scoring allowed but the burden of explanation is higher, and certain events cannot be held against you. |
Everything else โ Texas, Florida, Georgia, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Arizona, Colorado โ allows credit-based insurance scoring for both auto and home. In those states the score can move a premium by more than a hundred percent, and it can also decide whether you get a policy at all.
How much it actually costs you
Filed rate manuals make the spread explicit. Across the large personal-lines carriers, the difference between the best and worst credit tier commonly runs:
- Homeowners: 40% to 130% of the base premium
- Auto: 30% to 160% of the base premium, and wider in states with fewer filing restrictions
- Renters: 20% to 90%, which matters because renters policies are small enough that people rarely re-shop them
Translate that into money. On a $1,600 homeowners premium, moving from a poor tier to a good one is worth roughly $500โ$900 a year โ every year, for as long as the score stays there. On two cars at $2,400 combined, the swing can exceed $1,000.
What insurers cannot legally do
Even in permissive states, the rules are not a blank check. Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and state insurance codes, a carrier must:
- Tell you it used credit. An adverse-action notice is required if you are declined, rated up, or non-renewed because of your credit report.
- Name the reporting agency. The notice must identify the bureau so you can pull the report yourself โ free, within 60 days.
- Re-underwrite after a correction. If the report was wrong and you get it fixed, the insurer must re-rate the policy and refund the difference from the effective date.
- Ignore certain events. Most states forbid penalizing you for a medical collection, a pandemic-era hardship flagged under state rules, or inquiries made by insurance companies themselves.
- Not use it as the sole reason in restricted states. Oregon and Washington require other factors to carry weight.
That third point is where most of the money is recovered. Bureaus make errors at scale โ a settled collection still reported as open, a closed account listed as delinquent, an identity mix-up with a relative who shares your name. Every one of those errors shows up in your insurance score.
How to fix the number that actually matters
- Pull all three bureau reports. AnnualCreditReport.com, free weekly. Dispute in writing, not by phone โ you want a paper trail and a date.
- Kill utilization first. Paying a balance down below 30% of the limit, then below 10%, moves insurance models faster than anything else you can do in a month.
- Do not close old accounts. Length of history is a positive factor; closing a ten-year-old card to “tidy up” can cost you a tier.
- Ask for a re-rate, in writing. Send the corrected report to your agent with a request to re-run the score and re-rate from the policy’s effective date. Insurers rarely volunteer this.
- Re-shop after 60 days. A new score means new quotes. In auto, this is often worth more than every discount on the menu combined.
Tier placement, not just price
Credit also decides placement. A weak score can push an otherwise clean risk out of the preferred company and into a subsidiary with a different name, a different claims operation, and a materially higher rate โ or into the residual market entirely. If you have been quoted a number that seems disconnected from your driving record or your roof age, ask the agent one direct question: which tier was I placed in, and was credit a factor? You are entitled to a straight answer.
Related reading: how state-approved discounts stack against each other, why territory and catastrophe load drive home rates, and what to do when a claim goes sideways โ our guide to filing a complaint with your state insurance department.
Frequently asked questions
Does checking my own credit hurt my insurance score?
No. Consumer-initiated inquiries are not counted, and insurance inquiries are excluded in most state models. Only applications for new credit count.
Can an insurer raise my rate mid-policy because of credit?
Not retroactively. Insurers re-score at renewal, and in several states they must give notice before applying an increase. A mid-term increase tied to credit is generally not permitted.
I have no credit history at all. Am I penalized?
Often, yes โ “no hit” is treated as a poor tier in many models. Some carriers offer a no-hit exception or use alternate data. Ask specifically; it is a legitimate underwriting question and it is not always advertised.
Does a bankruptcy stay on my insurance score forever?
No. It is time-limited in the models โ typically seven years โ and its weight declines well before it drops off. Recovering the tier usually takes two to three years of clean payment history.
Do all insurers weight credit the same way?
No. Two carriers using the same bureau can produce different tiers because their proprietary models weight variables differently. That is exactly why re-shopping the same risk across five carriers produces five different prices.
Can I ask to be rated without credit?
In ban states, credit is not used at all. Elsewhere, a few carriers will quote a no-credit rate on request โ usually higher, occasionally competitive. It costs nothing to ask.
Does credit affect commercial or umbrella policies?
Commercial underwriting may consider business credit; personal umbrella policies are frequently scored on the underlying home and auto tier. If your umbrella premium jumped without a claim, ask whether credit re-scoring was the trigger.
Read next: average car insurance cost by state in 2026 and the cheapest minimum-coverage rates by state, where credit tier explains most of the gap between the headline number and your actual quote.
Leave a Reply